Web/Marketplace Features

Marketplace and SL websites
  • Search existing ideas before submitting
  • Use support.secondlife.com for customer support issues
  • Keep posts on-topic
Thank you for your ideas!
Specific Regulations Addressing Scam Items using AI and Outside 3D renders of products to Mislead the End user and consumer.
There has been a recent proliferation of dishonest marketplace sellers using AI, DAZ renders, and other outside programs to generate imagery for Marketplace products to mislead buyers about what the product is and how it works. I strongly believe that this proliferation is harming the usability and integrity of the SL Marketplace for the end consumer of SL Products. You have a rash of sellers reselling freely available scripts at inflated prices using imagery that blatantly misrepresents what the product does. The Marketplace guidelines clearly state: "When including pictures in your listings, use a picture that accurately represents your item so that buyers are not confused about what you're selling" as mentioned here: https://marketplace.secondlife.com/listing_guidelines . The problem already existed previously, but is now so much worse and I think it is killing the Marketplace as a whole. Despite this being a guideline, it seems to not always be strongly enforced. I am asking LL to please consider updating their listing guidelines to specifically name purely AI generated imagery and 3D renders in outside programs such as DAZ in a new update of the listing guidelines. I am also asking LL to considering having Trust and Safety more regularly monitor the Scripting section of the Marketplace to better ensure the integrity of purchased items. This is especially true since scripts and animations cannot as easily have Demos as say, clothing or hair products. Thank you for your time.
0
·
Marketplace
Add marketplace policy regarding AI generated content
So going into this, I want to disclaim that I myself am not against AI. I personally have used it before, and will do so in the future. A specific chat AI helps me regularly with solving problems. However, I am against people intentionally misleading people about content, and polluting search results with content made in mere seconds, and find it no different than spam. If I made something that randomly generated randomly colored squares on a white canvas, and listed it a dozen or so times, it'd be seen as spam. Additionally, this issue was brought up in the SL Discord marketplace chat. I've moved it here so that it can get more recognition and visibility to LL. Personally, I believe that a policy worded like so would benefit everyone in the long run (canny has messed up some formatting here, so it looks like it has no line breaks, these have been substituted with "---" for readability) Content that is the sole generation of Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning, or otherwise Generative Content, except in the cases where the generator was written for the sole purpose of generating a specific element, may not be listed on the Marketplace as-is or as the focal point of the content that is listed. --- AI images must never be used to generate listing images, and must be presented as the content appears in SL. Overlays, such as permission information, price, branding labels, or sales labels, are permitted as much so as they do not mis-represent the content that is being advertised. --- Examples of forbidden listings: * In singular or collection, AI generated content as a texture, image, mesh, sound or other type of asset, as the sole content being listed. * A AI generated image in a picture frame. * A museum prefab filled with AI generated images as a "ready to go" model. * A object that plays randomly generated AI voice clips. * Attempting to pass off or mislead people that AI generated content as original, hand crafted content. * A listing which shows a AI enhanced product preview. --- Examples of allowed listings: * A house that has a AI generated poster in it, where the poster is not the selling point of the house. * A museum model that has some AI generated images, or is focused on the topic of AI generated content. * A NPC, that among other features, plays AI generated voice clips. * A model that has AI generated textures, where the model is not AI generated. --- Listings that make use of 50% or more in it's creation must be clearly labeled as using AI generation or assistance in the listing description. Interpretation of what counts as "50% or more is" left solely to Linden Lab. Listings that use AI but under the 50% threshold are recommended, but not required, to disclose that AI is used in some capacity. In summary, it forbids listing of content on the marketplace, free or for sale, that is entirely AI generated, requires disclosure of AI generated content when AI does a majority of the work, and guards against some loopholes. This probably (as in, very likely. I feel this is implied, but just in case) isn't needed, but: Because this will probably get passed by the lawyers, I hereby grant all permission to Linden Lab to use or transform the above work in any way, without attribution or compensation. Linden Lab has the opportunity to deal with this now before it gets too out of control. Only a handful of residents would be in violation of this policy. This also only applies to marketplace stuff, not in-world content.
124
·
Marketplace
·
tracked
ADD Do Not Show "AI Generated" Filter on Marketplace
Please add a required bool while creating a Marketplace listing that asks the creator to disclose if AI generative tools were used in part/all of the products creation. Add this bool to the 'Do Not Show' section of the Marketplace search filter. Allow listings to be reported if they do not honestly disclose this. ---- For the health of the market we need the use of AI tools to be disclosed by creators. I would prefer personally that no AI generation be supported. I understand that tolorance of it is an effort to avoid censorships slippery slope, and is complicated by the sheer variation of AI tools that currently exist. But regardless of opinions or complications, it's existance cannot be ignored. So lets focus on what can be done, by giving some power of choice to the consumer instead. Users should be provided a way to choose products with or without AI generation while shopping, and naturally creators who choose not to disclose or to lie should face the same reportability and moderation as any other creator that would choose to lie while listing. The moderation half of this should not necessarily focus on trying to prove the use of AI gen tools, it doesn't actually need to. Creators who have done the work to provide support and actually prepare the AI generated content for its use in SL are unlikely to warrent being reported, and should not need to lie about the useage anyway. It is products that blatantly lack support, have egregious LOD & LI values that would be inclined to lie, and would want to be reported by users, this is the same for ANY product currently listed. If you buy it, and you don't get what was described, it should be reportable, the same goes for AI generated products, AI generated should not get a pass because you have to 'prove' something first, when the fact remains that you didn't get what thought you bought. So do not focus on "did you use a tool?" focus on "can you fix & support the product?" If it can't be supported, then disclose it was made via AI generation and move on. This is a similar complication to full perm and gacha resales, but also ripped models, copybot etc, in they will all lack support due to not being made directly by the creator of the listing. There is a big difference between fullperm & gacha resale vs ripping & botting, and that difference is honest disclosure.
331
·
Marketplace
·
tracked
Track Our Product Royalties
When a creator, collaborator, or business partner is promised a percentage of a product’s sales, there is currently no clear and reliable way for that person to confirm whether the agreed revenue share has been applied. They may also have no way to verify that they are still assigned a percentage of the product’s sale price. I would like Second Life to provide a dedicated revenue-sharing page or dashboard, accessible through the Second Life website, Marketplace, or Viewer. It should show live or near-real-time information for every product from which a user is entitled to receive a percentage. Ideally, the dashboard would show: The product name and listing or object ID. The product’s current sale price. The user’s assigned percentage or fixed share. Whether the revenue-sharing arrangement is currently active. The user’s expected and actual payment from each sale. The date and time of each sale and payment. A history of changes to the user’s percentage, including when it was added, changed, or removed. A notification whenever a revenue-sharing agreement is changed or removed. For privacy, collaborators would only need to see information related to their own share. The product owner could retain access to the complete sales information. Trust is a major part of collaborations in Second Life, but collaborators should not have to rely on trust alone when money is involved. A transparent record would prevent misunderstandings, make revenue-sharing agreements easier to verify, and build greater confidence between creators, business partners, affiliates, and other contributors. If complete sales reporting is not possible, even a simpler page confirming the product, current sale price, active revenue-share status, assigned percentage, and payment history would be a valuable improvement.
1
·
tracked
Product Unlisting & Store Disabling Policy - Warning Reminder
When I read the following policy from the URL provided below - https://community.secondlife.com/news/featured-news/improving-marketplace-search-and-product-discovery-r11329/ I noticed that it has no mention of a non-login warning reminder for those who have an alt account as their store owner. I say this because some store owners out there either have one store on an alt for peace of mind purposes or simply have more than one store in which they end up with a few alt accounts as owners / representors of said stores. It would be appropriate to allow store owners the ability to designate 2 accounts if need be to give a warning to and 1 email contact since even the account email might be different than the one they usually use/access. This at least brings SL closer to something similar to the current recovery standards that well known businesses like Google, AT&T, Yahoo, and Microsoft as examples allow you to do. Since as an example Google at least gives you an ample succession of warnings in time starting a few months in advance so that you can login to your alt accounts in time before it's too late. Would also help if the warning went to the store manager(s) as well in case it might be easier for them to contact the store owner too to handle the situation faster. Yet for store managers, allow the store owner to decide if the warning goes to the manager(s) or not through an option in the manager permissions menu.
4
·
Marketplace
·
tracked
Store Co-Owner Option
There are stores out there with 2 or 3 owners for whatever reason. You might have one or two that do just the mesh and textures while the last person does the scripting. That or various other versions of setup such as 1 doing mesh and the other does rigging. Even seen one for mesh and the other for texturing. Also seen someone that does just the pictures and store setup while the other does just texturing or mesh and texturing. That's just the usual ones I've seen when it comes to store co-owners who have their own skillsets that mix well with someone else that has that missing needed ability to make great products together. Another thing to note is that most if not all of the products in these types of stores are evenly or fairly split on the revenue. While at the same time the products are more or less split fairly enough on task for who does what. Normally in the past nothing would be a problem when the co-owner is set as a manager, but with that new "Product Unlisting Policy" and "Store Disabling Policy" that specifically targets the owner on if that said owner logs in, this policy can be unfair to the other owners that still manage the store through answering customer questions or as a user with manager rights while earning. Since it doesn't help that the Product Unlisting Policy has a knock-on effect to the Store Disabling Policy. I know that people might say, that a few people could try to make an account that multiple co-owners could log into through with a name that is basically the same as the store name, but problem with that at times is that someone might try to change the password or other factors. Like if its a partner and there is a divorce, then who keeps the account. That or two friends or two siblings use that store account and they have a falling out one day. In other words, that's not always the best option when a store co-owner option could be there. Course I'm sure there are legal ways with a lawyer helping to have people share a specifically made store account but not everyone has the money or means for that when it would be simpler to just add a co-owner ability to a store. Plus doing this goes along the lines of the following: https://wiki.secondlife.com/wiki/Linden_Lab_Official:Death_and_other_worries_outside_Second_Life Though with the store co-owner suggestion, this at least gives people in general less legalese hassles to deal with when it's just a straight forward join as co-owner option. Just like it's straight forward to add someone as a partner inworld or to add someone as a owner in a group. Yet yeah there will be just the one person who created the store, just like the one person who created a group. The founder of it if you will. Yet if this is added then at least this allows the store co-owner to upload stuff to the store and do the rest of the stuff that the manager role does too. Plus if the "View Audit Logs" page is utilized with this, it's an easy way to see who's been doing what as well if needed. Point is, at least give co-owners of a store an easier ability and chance to work on the store and add listings, while keeping a store running if something happens to the other owner if/when health issues arrive.
0
·
Marketplace
Allow for reporting AI generated content marketplace listings or Video game model theft.
Every day I watch the "complete avatars" category on the marketplace Every day there's 5 new avatars, all game model rips, generated image ads, generated 3D model avatars, or a swath of wrongly categorized low effort AI content. There's a few small number of users uploading a massive amount of marketplace listing, all mass uploaded game rips, or generated avatars, so much so, that it completely overshadows any genuinely created user content. I used to look forward to seeing artistic creations, or originality, inventiveness and ingenuity. Now all I see is 100 low effort avatars, and 1 genuine avatar rarely posted once a month. Why would this suggestion help? 1.) Lowers mass storage of irrelevant content 2.) Creates relevance, and helps with the tagging system as a whole, enriching user interaction with the marketplace as a whole 3.) Allows for more creative content with worth and depth. I know there has been a few posts on this already, but quickly the marketplace has become the last place people are wanting to look when purchasing things from other users; it lowers profit, it lowers worth, it lowers desire to even use the platform. more and more people are choosing to only go to events instead of even looking at the marketplace. its quickly becoming almost useless for its intended purpose, if everything on there is just 1000 bland badly rigged fortnite avatars, game imports or randomly generated AI characters, again badly rigged. Quality over quantity, any day, please.
12
Load More
→